I’ve always had a problem with “historical” war films that freely mix facts with fiction and still market themselves as true stories. Creative liberty is fine. Intellectual dishonesty isn’t.

Border (1997) worked despite its flaws. The music was iconic, the emotions landed, and most importantly, the film stayed focused on one battle — Longewala. Even though the real battle didn’t unfold exactly the way the movie showed it, the scale, stakes, and tension felt authentic. That focus was its biggest strength.

Border 2 (2026) throws that discipline out of the window.

The songs are forgettable. The story is almost non-existent. The plot feels like a lazy adaptation of Border, except the writers forgot why the original worked in the first place. Instead of committing to a single battle and doing justice to it, the film crams three different battles into one runtime, resulting in a rushed narrative with zero depth.

The first half is nothing but recycled backstories — clichés we’ve already seen in a dozen war films. Nothing new. Nothing insightful. Nothing even particularly entertaining. Especially after Dhurandhar setting new standards for film making, Border 2 does look like a parody.

But the real problem isn’t cinematic.
It’s historical.

---

The Battle of Basantar: What the Film Gets Wrong

The depiction of the Battle of Basantar (1971) is where Border 2 completely collapses as a serious war film.

---

This Was a Tank Battle — And the Film Pretends It Wasn’t

Most unforgivable of all is what Border 2 chooses to erase.

The Battle of Basantar was fundamentally an armoured engagement. Infantry courage mattered, but the outcome was decided by tanks, artillery, engineers, and coordination across arms. Strip that away and you’re no longer telling history — you’re selling a myth.

On the Indian side, the fighting was carried by:

• Centurion tanks, the proven workhorse of Indian armoured regiments
• Vijayanta tanks, India’s first indigenously produced main battle tank

These units bore the brunt of repeated Pakistani counterattacks after the Basantar river crossing.

Opposing them were Pakistani formations heavily equipped with American-supplied M47 and M48 Patton tanks. After 1965, the Patton wasn’t just hardware — it was doctrine. By 1971, the belief that Pattons could dominate any battlefield had hardened into institutional arrogance.

Basantar shattered that belief.

---

The Reality Behind the “Patton Graveyard”

This was one of the battles where the term “Patton graveyard” earned renewed meaning.

When the fighting ended:

• Dozens of Patton tanks lay destroyed, disabled, or abandoned
• Many were captured intact, victims of mine damage, mechanical failure, or crew panic under sustained artillery and armoured fire
• Indian artillery and armour did the decisive heavy lifting, breaking successive Pakistani armoured thrusts

The psychological impact was as significant as the material loss. A tank once believed to be unbeatable had been reduced to scrap metal.

---

The Minefields — Bravery Erased

The movie shows Indian soldiers planting mines.

That is factually wrong.

The minefields were laid by the Pakistan Army. Indian engineers and infantry had to clear those mines under intense enemy fire to allow armor to advance. This was one of the most dangerous and heroic phases of the battle.

Why not show that?

Because it would have highlighted collective courage — engineers, infantry, and armor working together — instead of reducing the narrative to a single hero’s bravado. Indian war cinema has a long-standing addiction to hero worship, and Border 2 is no exception.

---

The Film’s Biggest Historical Confusion

Border 2 visually borrows a famous tank-luring trope — but from the wrong war and the wrong battle.

The deliberate tactic of drawing Pakistani Patton tanks into a terrain trap belongs to the Battle of Asal Uttar (1965), not Basantar.

In 1965:

• Indian forces breached irrigation canals, flooding agricultural land
• Pakistani Patton tanks, believed to be unstoppable, followed Indian withdrawals
• Over 90 Patton tanks became bogged down in swampy fields — immobilized, abandoned, or destroyed. Haha Dhappa moment!

That battlefield became the original and most iconic “Patton graveyard.”

By transplanting this imagery into a 1971 setting, Border 2 collapses two very different battles into one generic cinematic fantasy. Basantar’s reality revolved around mine-clearing, night river crossings, and armored counterattacks — not the warfare shown in the movie.

---

Why This Matters

By sidelining tanks and artillery, the film reduces the battle to background noise punctuated by shouting slogans and slow-motion heroics. Infantry bravery deserves respect — but pretending Basantar wasn’t a tank-dominated battle is historical malpractice.

War is not won by bravado.
It is won by:

• Logistics
• Firepower
• Engineering
• Coordination between infantry, armour, and artillery
• Sacrifice across units — not just one face on the screen

Border 2 ignores all of that.

---

Major Hoshiar Singh — Timing Matters

The Movie’s Version: The “Suicide” Charge

In the film, Major Hoshiar (Varun Dhawan) leads his men across open terrain in broad daylight.

In reality, such an assault against an entrenched enemy supported by tanks and machine guns would have been a massacre, not bravery. The portrayal makes the Indian Army look reckless — dependent on luck and shouting rather than discipline and training.

The Reality: The Silent Night Strike

The real capture of Jarpal by 3 Grenadiers was a textbook night operation.

• Timing: The advance began around 10:00 PM, 15 December 1971
• Method: Silent river crossing under cover of darkness
• Combat: Close-quarters fighting, including bayonet charges in the dark

This wasn’t cinematic chest-thumping. It was professional soldiering at its finest — and far more terrifying than what the film shows.

---

The Bigger Problem

By getting these details wrong, Border 2 doesn’t just fail as a film — it fails as a tribute.

The real Battle of Basantar was far more dramatic, far more complex, and far more heroic than what the movie shows. The irony is painful: reality didn’t need exaggeration.

If you’re going to rewrite history, at least make it better than the truth.

Border 2 doesn’t.

Thanks for reading!

What do you think about the Navy and Airforce actions shown in the movie? what’s fact and what’s fiction? If you enjoyed reading this and found something interesting, subscribe to the blog and let me know what you think.

Also read:

• The Cultural Trauma of Dhurandhar: Why ‘Arfa Khanum’ Can’t Reconcile with the New Reality
• Thamma: Bollywood’s Vampire Saga That’s Too Familiar
• The Two reasons why they don’t want you to watch Dhurandhar!
• The Sham of Indian Feminism: Absent from Cricket’s Triumph, Obsessed with Selective Outrage
• Mandala Murders: A Portal to Elsewhere, Where Imagination Reigns
• The Sacred Games we were always a part of